Learn to guide children instead of hitting them: A discussion for teachers and parents
American School Science Academy
Dalan, Katihar - 854106
Today's discussion
- The reality today
- The effects of hitting children
- Who should decide on punishment?
- What the law says
- Positive discipline
- Our pledge
The reality today: Hitting is still common at home and in school
In India, many parents and teachers still believe that corporal punishment is the most effective way to instil good values in children. Some common forms include:
- Slapping
- Beating with a cane or stick
- Pulling a child's ears
- Making a child crouch and hold their ears from between their legs as punishment
- Making a child stand in the sun
- Making a child do repeated squats
Insults, taunts, threats and public humiliation can be just as harmful, even when they leave no visible marks.
Common beliefs: What we believe and what is true
| Belief | Reality |
|---|---|
| "Hitting makes a child behave better." | Hitting makes a child keep quiet out of fear; it does not teach them to understand right and wrong. |
| "We were hit too, and we turned out fine." | We turned out fine despite being hit, not because of it. |
| "There is no discipline without fear." | Fear brings obedience, not respect and understanding. |
| "It is for the child's own good." | Pain and humiliation leave deep wounds rather than helping a child. |
Remember: Hitting teaches a child to be afraid, not to improve
Fear may produce immediate obedience, but it does not build respect, understanding or good values.
The effects on behaviour: Hitting increases misbehaviour instead of reducing it
- Anger and aggression: The child learns that force is a way to get what they want, and uses it against others.
- Lying and hiding mistakes: Fear of punishment makes the child stop telling the truth.
- Stubbornness and rebellion: The child stays quiet in front of adults but does the forbidden thing behind their backs.
- Loss of trust: The child stops confiding in parents or teachers, even when in trouble.
The effects on the mind and development: A child's mind cannot thrive in fear
- Fear and anxiety: Living with a constant fear of punishment.
- Lower self-confidence: Developing thoughts such as "I am bad."
- Effects on learning: Fear weakens attention and memory.
- Fear of school: Avoiding school or dropping out.
- Loneliness: Withdrawing from friends and family.
- Sadness and irritability: Crying or becoming angry over small things.
The effects into adulthood: Some wounds last a lifetime
The cycle can continue: being hit in childhood leads to fear and anger, the same approach is used in adulthood, and the next generation is also hit.
- A greater risk of sadness and depression
- Difficulty controlling anger
- Relationship difficulties and mistrust
- Low self-worth and living in constant fear
What research says: The scientific conclusion is clear
Decades of research have found that corporal punishment does not produce lasting improvements in children's behaviour.
Instead, it has been linked to greater aggression, antisocial behaviour and mental health problems. This also applies to "light" hitting.
The World Health Organization (WHO) considers corporal punishment harmful to children and recommends ending it.
The most important question
Are we qualified to decide which child needs to be hit?
Before punishing a child, we assume that we know everything: what the child did, why they did it and what they need. Most of the time, we do not know these things, and our decision is driven by our anger, tiredness or prejudice.
Who should decide on punishment? The hidden reasons behind "bad behaviour"
- Hunger or lack of sleep
- Illness or physical pain
- Difficulty with reading and writing, such as dyslexia
- Difficulty sustaining attention, such as ADHD
- Stress or arguments at home
- Bullying by peers
A child's behaviour is a message. Understand it first, then respond.
What the law says: Corporal punishment in school is illegal
- Right to Education Act, 2009 (Section 17): Prohibits corporal punishment and mental harassment of children in school. Violations can lead to disciplinary action.
- National Commission for Protection of Child Rights: Has issued guidelines for eliminating corporal punishment in schools.
- Juvenile Justice Act, 2015 (Section 82): Corporal punishment of children in child care institutions is a punishable offence.
- United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child: India accepted it in 1992. Every child has the right to protection from all forms of violence (Article 19).
A better approach: Positive discipline means learning, not punishment
| Aspect | Corporal punishment | Positive discipline |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | To cause pain and fear | To teach appropriate behaviour |
| What the child learns | To be afraid and hide things | To think and make good choices |
| Relationship | Fear and distance | Trust and respect |
| Effect | Short-lived | Lasting |
Positive discipline does not mean being permissive. It involves clear rules and consequences for mistakes, without hitting or humiliation.
For teachers: Classroom discipline without hitting
- Develop classroom rules together with the children.
- Praise good behaviour promptly and openly.
- When a child makes a mistake, first understand the reason; speak calmly with them in private.
- Make learning interesting; boredom often leads to mischief.
- Use a logical consequence for a mistake, such as cleaning up a mess the child has made.
- For recurring problems, meet with the parents and a counsellor.
For parents: Teaching good values at home without hitting
- Set an example yourself; children learn by watching.
- Listen carefully to your child every day.
- Keep household rules and routines clear and consistent.
- Praise good actions instead of only pointing out mistakes.
- Use logical consequences for mistakes, such as temporarily restricting mobile phone use.
- Spend some time with your child every day.
When you feel angry: Four steps before raising your hand
- Stop: Stop what you were about to do.
- Breathe: Take a deep breath and slowly count to 10.
- Step away: If necessary, leave the situation for a few minutes.
- Talk: Once you are calm, speak to the child with care and affection.
The anger belongs to the adult; the child should not be punished for it.
Our pledge: Let us make this commitment together
- We will not raise a hand against any child.
- We will avoid humiliating, intimidating or threatening children.
- Before considering punishment, we will listen to the child and understand the reasons for their behaviour.
- Home and school will work together to create a safe environment for children.
Every child deserves love and respect.
Thank you. Your questions and thoughts are welcome.
American School Science Academy, Dalan, Katihar - 854106